|
|
Post by sambob on Aug 5, 2008 22:55:41 GMT
This'l bring in some god-mode civil war mfb: I agree with debbie  haha not really, just think theyr pish nto a waste of space, heard theyr dead sound lads tho love you really though man  |
|
|
|
Post by MFB on Aug 5, 2008 23:00:34 GMT
We're having this discussion on msn.
I see no valid argument as to why they're "a waste of space" or "utterly terrible"
It's just plain ignorance to slate a band who play music of a genre you don't like.
|
|
dhanig
New Member
Clubnights Mod
Posts: 85
|
Post by dhanig on Aug 5, 2008 23:01:43 GMT
i think there new stuff is quality
|
|
John FTW
New Member
Just so you know for my first few posts i was trolling as hitler :P
Posts: 74
|
Post by John FTW on Aug 5, 2008 23:51:02 GMT
I see no valid argument as to why they're "a waste of space" or "utterly terrible". Its because they ARE a waste of space and utterly terrible martin. I mean they made there name from having lyrics about bleeding vaginas and "bree", which wee scenester wanks found funny. Nothing with any sort of great musical merit or lyrical meaning whatsoever! They where also basically "Waking The Cadaver v2.0" and around the time they came out,everyone was loving the absolute garbage that is, Waking The Cadaver because it was the trendy thing to like BREEBREEetc. So if a band was to come around with a similar style in the uk its obvious they where going to get a small amount of sucess with that trend wank And as far the new stuff goes YAWN is my opinion. |
|
|
|
Post by MFB on Aug 6, 2008 0:01:46 GMT
It's all you opinion.
Sorry, did you play Download?
Are you gigging?
Do you even have 1000+ fans?
Ha. No.
|
|
dhanig
New Member
Clubnights Mod
Posts: 85
|
Post by dhanig on Aug 6, 2008 0:06:06 GMT
is anything that comes from that boy worth reading at all?
|
|
John FTW
New Member
Just so you know for my first few posts i was trolling as hitler :P
Posts: 74
|
Post by John FTW on Aug 6, 2008 0:11:26 GMT
It's all you opinion. Sorry, did you play Download? Are you gigging? Do you even have 1000+ fans? Ha. No. Yes it is opinion and i stated mine. And wow you are going into THAT arguement. If you're going to use that, you better atleast be ready to admit that Britney Spears is better than BTBAM or Architects because she has sold a shit tonne more records than them. Just because something sells alot doesn't mean its good. |
|
John FTW
New Member
Just so you know for my first few posts i was trolling as hitler :P
Posts: 74
|
Post by John FTW on Aug 6, 2008 0:15:09 GMT
is anything that comes from that boy worth reading at all? Nope. Walk on. |
|
jimmy
New Member
Posts: 54
|
Post by jimmy on Aug 6, 2008 0:15:45 GMT
I see no valid argument as to why they're "a waste of space" or "utterly terrible". Its because they ARE a waste of space and utterly terrible martin. I mean they made there name from having lyrics about bleeding vaginas and "bree", which wee scenester wanks found funny. Nothing with any sort of great musical merit or lyrical meaning whatsoever! They where also basically "Waking The Cadaver v2.0" and around the time they came out,everyone was loving the absolute garbage that is, Waking The Cadaver because it was the trendy thing to like BREEBREEetc. So if a band was to come around with a similar style in the uk its obvious they where going to get a small amount of sucess with that trend wank And as far the new stuff goes YAWN is my opinion. Waking The Cadaver were cool about 2 years before 'AOAA' so you're incorrect about that and you can't say anything about their lyrics until you write them yourself to be honest. |
|
|
|
Post by MFB on Aug 6, 2008 0:18:53 GMT
The fact it sells more, generally means it's popular.
Britney Spears has a bigger fanbase, as the music is more "socially" excepted, or rather... welcomed.
This all comes down to opinion, like you've said. I was defending my opinion of AoAA against Debbie and this evolved. I still stand by the fact, that if they're selling albums, merch, getting gigs, gaining popularity they MUST be doing something right.
They may not be quite your taste, or other peoples either. This doesn't mean they're terrible. The fact they've utilized the "scene market" does not make them terrible. They may "BREEBREEetc," they may sing about bleeding genitals, but who cares. They're selling it, so OBVIOUSLY they're doing something right.
As I've said before, they may not be YOUR TYPE of music, as Britney Spears may not be, as Marvin Gaye, as Cliff Richard may not be, but fact is there's a market for them out there. It may not appeal to you, but it sure as hell appeals to other people.
You can't slate a band because they don't play the music you like.
P.S - lol 1000 words.
|
|
John FTW
New Member
Just so you know for my first few posts i was trolling as hitler :P
Posts: 74
|
Post by John FTW on Aug 6, 2008 0:25:10 GMT
Crazy frog MUST be doing something right. And jimmy my point was they where cashing on the bree thing. And you don't have to be a chef to know bad food TBH. |
|
|
|
Post by MFB on Aug 6, 2008 0:30:03 GMT
Crazy frog MUST be doing something right. Crazy Frog appealed to some people. Who're you to say he wasn't doing something wrong. It's a retarded argument, if you are just reiterating what I am saying, I will just ignore it, because you lose validity. |
|
John FTW
New Member
Just so you know for my first few posts i was trolling as hitler :P
Posts: 74
|
Post by John FTW on Aug 6, 2008 0:40:31 GMT
Crazy frog MUST be doing something right. Crazy Frog appealed to some people. Who're you to say he wasn't doing something wrong. It's a retarded argument, if you are just reiterating what I am saying, I will just ignore it, because you lose validity. Yes Yes Martin you do have a point. However its slightly worrying if you're going to go on this everytime someone bad mouths a band thats had some success. |
|
|
|
Post by MFB on Aug 6, 2008 0:44:00 GMT
Everytime?
Do elaborate.
AoAA and Crazy Frog are the only 2 discussed. I'm only defending them because it makes no feasible sense to SLATE a band you DON'T LIKE.
Bias much?
|
|
|
|
Post by plagues on Aug 7, 2008 8:54:43 GMT
yeah annotations are getting some success. I Hate their music though  but thats just my opinion, i'm sure their not a waste of space lol i just don't like the music. i could be wrong the ymight put on a sick live show. Just never saw them cause their songs put me off going any where near them lol just so happens born of osiris are playing this so i must be there haha |
|
